Huntington Employment Lawyer

Suing over an NDA can be illegal retaliation, New York court rules

Four New York workplace developments from the week of October 19–23, 2026, and what each one means if you are an employee or an employer.


An employer that fights back with a confidentiality agreement may be retaliating

(Denson v. Donald J. Trump for President, Inc., 2026 NY Slip Op 06197, App. Div., 1st Dep’t, Oct. 22, 2026)

A woman who worked on a presidential campaign sued for discrimination. A month later, the campaign filed a $1.5 million claim against her, saying her lawsuit itself broke the non-disclosure agreement she had signed. A Manhattan appeals court ruled that a jury can decide whether filing that claim was retaliation under New York City’s Human Rights Law — a violation in its own right, separate from the original discrimination case.

Three facts drove the result. The campaign gave one reason in a sworn statement and a different one at deposition. It demanded $1.5 million but could not show it had lost any money. And it had brought similar claims against other former staffers who complained.

For employees: If you complain about discrimination and your employer responds by threatening or suing you over a confidentiality or non-disparagement clause, that response may itself be unlawful. The agreement does not have to be invalid for this to apply.

For employers: Before sending a demand letter to someone who has just sued you, settle on one reason and write it down, be able to prove any dollar figure you claim, and distinguish in writing between what actually breaches the agreement and what is a protected complaint. A sincere belief the agreement was broken is a defense to be tested, not an automatic answer.

A contract that lets the employer reassign your duties is hard to fight

(Perez v. Premier Home Health Care Services, Inc., 2026 NY Slip Op 06153, App. Div., 2d Dep’t, Oct. 21, 2026)

A general counsel signed a three-year contract. Near the end of the term, the CEO told him the company could no longer afford his position and that he should stop coming in. He sued, arguing he had effectively been fired and was owed severance.

He lost. His contract said his duties were “commensurate with the position of General Counsel” and could be assigned by the CEO or the board. He also kept doing legal work and was paid under the contract through the end of the term. Because he was never actually terminated, no severance was owed.

For employees: A broad clause letting the employer assign your duties will usually defeat a claim that your role was stripped. If severance matters to you, negotiate specific triggers — a change in title, reporting line, budget, or headcount — rather than relying on how a demotion feels.

For employers: Letting a nearly expired contract run out on full pay and benefits is defensible. Cutting it short is what creates the severance obligation.

Public discipline requires written paperwork — but the agency may get a second chance

(Matter of Lindo v. Ponte, 2026 NY Slip Op 06118, App. Div., 2d Dep’t, Oct. 21, 2026)

When a public agency disciplines an employee, the official running the hearing must be designated in writing. A Brooklyn appeals court confirmed that without that designation the hearing officer’s ruling is void, no matter what the hearing found.

The correction officer here still lost. An earlier appeal had sent the case back for this exact reason, and the Department of Correction then produced a 2012 letter designating the hearing office’s chief judge and any judge she assigned. That was enough.

For employees: Ask whether the written designation exists, and raise it at the hearing. Waiting until appeal can give the agency time to locate the document.

For employers: A standing, blanket designation covering a chief hearing officer and assigned deputies satisfies the rule, and a predecessor’s signature is fine. Confirm one is on file for everyone who presides.

Restaurant tip rules loosened federally — but not in New York

(U.S. Department of Labor, Field Assistance Bulletin No. 2026-1, Oct. 19, 2026; 12 NYCRR § 146-2.9)

The U.S. Department of Labor withdrew the rule limiting how much untipped side work a tipped employee can be given. New York has its own, stricter rule, and it did not change.

For employees: If you spend two hours, or more than 20 percent of a shift, on untipped work, your employer cannot pay you the lower tipped wage for that entire day — whichever of those two limits is reached first.

For employers: Do not rewrite your New York tip practices to match the federal standard. New York’s rule is per day and all-or-nothing, so the control is the schedule: a two-hour prep block has already cost the tip credit for that shift.


This post discusses published decisions and agency guidance for informational purposes. It is not legal advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship. The decisions may be appealed, modified, or superseded.

Get Your First Consultation FREE!

Yale Pollack

Meet Yale Pollack, Esq.

After earning his bachelor’s degree from Colgate University in 2001, Mr. Pollack graduated magna cum laude from Touro Law Center in 2006, where he served on the law review. He then gained extensive litigation experience at a respected Long Island law firm, handling labor and employment matters as well as business, contract, and civil disputes. Today, he brings that depth of experience to every client he serves.

Email: ypollack@yalepollacklaw.com

Phone: 516-634-6340

If you believe your rights at work have been violated, call the Law Offices of Yale Pollack, P.C. at (516) 634-6340 for a free, confidential consultation.